Competitive analysis goal: compare the tone & content of each competitor's website
Name of Competitor | Website | Competitor type (Direct/Indirect) | Product/Service Offering | Target Audience | Unique Value Proposition | Type of Content | Content Categories | Quality of the Content | Topics They Cover | Voice | Tone | Readability | Accessibility | Navigation | Overall Impression |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Prison Education Project | www.pep.org | Indirect | Education, mentorship, | re entering formerly incarcerated individuals | 28 day prison to paycheck, high long term salary | Volunteer business plan mentorship | Construction, automotive, transportation, landscaping, apparel | Some sections are repetitive, particularly between “What We Do” and “In Prison/Post-Release” pages. Consolidating these could streamline the user experience | In prison initiatives, post release support, business education | The language is inspiring and action-oriented, aligning with the organization’s transformative mission. Terms like "revolution" and "fresh start" evoke optimism. | Alternative text available | Low contrast between text and background colors. | focus indicator not visible when using arrow keys | Compared to similar nonprofit organizations, PEP's emphasis on entrepreneurship is unique. However, its reliance on text-heavy pages could be balanced with more visuals, infographics, and interactive elements to convey its impact more dynamically. | |
Empowering Women Impacted by Incarceration | www.empoweringwomenii.org | Indirect | - Mental support |
Emotional Inflection: - Empathy and encouragement.
Perspective:
Evaluation: - Suitable for the audience.
| Sentence Length:
Complexity:
Jargon:
Adherence to Plain Language Principles: - Partially adherent (could use simpler sentence structures and concrete examples)
Overall Readability Score: - Moderate to Challenging. | Proper Heading Structure. - The content includes clear section tittles.
Language Complexity - The text uses formal and complex language, which could create barriers for users with cognitive disabilities or limited literacy.
Content Layout for Accessibility: - The content features long blocks of text, which can be overwhelming.
Contextual Information Missing in Links - Links lack context or descriptions, which impacts accessibility and user experience. | **- Contextual Information Missing in Links
Hidden Call-to-Action Buttons
Lack of Contact Options
Missing Social Media Links
Confusing Newsletter Subscription Process.** | While the website has a strong purpose and good intentions, its usability and accessibility challenges detract from its effectiveness. Improvements in navigation, call-to-actions, and overall structure would significantly enhance the user experience and better support the organization's goals. | | Impact Justice | https://impactjustice.org/ | indirect | - Homes for the formerly incarcerated
Mentorship
Creating opportunities for formerly and currently incarcerated people | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Root and Rebound | https://www.rootandrebound.org/ | indirect | -Reentry services for people impacted by incarceration
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | Defy Ventures | https://www.defyventures.org/ | Indirect | -Entrepreneur Bootcamp for formerly incarcerated people who have achieved stable housing and employment -Provides business accelerator programs to those who have done the entrepreneur bootcamp. | -Formerly incarcerated individuals who have since reentered the workforce and have stable housing. | -Empowering formerly incarcerated people to enter the business world reducing return-to-prison rates from over 30% to less than 10% | -For EITs (Entrepreneur in Training those entering the program) -For Volunteers -For donors | -Our story -Our Community -Take Action -Press -Blog -Shop | Most of the content is stories from EITs, Volunteers and other first hand experiences from people who have worked with the organization. Mostly quotes. There are longer form stories in the blog posts. | Stories from alumni of the group and community members | Professional, uplifting, at times somber and serious when talking about how incarceration effected them | -Inspiring, lots of talk of second chances and making change for the EITs -Emotional inflection, discussing impact as “meaningful impact” -Discussing how they can improve the system is hopeful. | Good readability. Sentences are short and longer paragraphs are kept in small blocks. , | Low accessibility. Poor contrast between text color and backgroud | Easy to navigate. Footer has site map and header has large and bold keywords for users. | Overall this is a good website easy to navigate and understand. I think it can be improved by having more information for the EITs. | | First Step Alliance | https://www.firststepalliance.org/ | Direct | | | | | | | | | | | | | |